Firstly, and most important for readers to know, 2019 is unquestionably a great vintage for Bordeaux. It has both incredible peaks of quality as well as a huge swath of beautiful wines – from all appellations and at all price points. If you look at the current list of benchmark vintages, including 1989, 1990, 2000, 2005, 2009, 2010, 2016, and 2018, the 2019 vintage may check in near the top of the list. While the vintage does not favor one bank over the other – there are beautiful wines from every appellation – 2019 is unquestionably greatest in Pomerol and the northern Médoc appellations of Saint-Julien and Pauillac.

While it’s always fun to consider similarities to older vintages when trying to understand current wines, given the changes in climate, vineyard management, and winemaking over the past 15 to 20 years, it’s becoming increasingly difficult to make these comparisons. The reality is that the wines today are vastly different from what was produced just two decades ago. Today’s modern Bordeaux have better purity of fruit, more (and better) tannins, better concentration, and more alcohol, all while showing softer, more approachable profiles that allow them to offer pleasure right out of the gate. Nevertheless, there were numerous times while tasting through these 2019s that I had the impression that I was tasting a modern-day version of the 1982s.  The 2019s have the ripe, sexy profiles of a warm, sunny year, yet the beautiful aromatics, terrific purity of fruit, and freshness of a cooler year. In addition, like the top 1982s, they stay light and graceful on the palate and will offer incredible drinking for most of their long lives.

While the 2019s aren’t the blockbuster styled wines of 2018 (and to a lesser extent 2009 and 2010), they have more sun-kissed profiles than the 2016s and strike an incredible balance between richness and freshness. Compared to more recent vintages, 2019 can be thought of as a more elegant version of 2009. I think Château Lafite’s technical director, Eric Kohler, summed it up nicely when he called the vintage “classic yet modern.”

Lastly, given that prices can be down as much as 20-30%, this is an opportunity for consumers to buy a great vintage – at solid prices. However, as I wrote in Part 1, make sure you understand the retailer’s policy regarding future tariffs and how that will affect the final price before buying!

The Growing Season

Undeniably, Bordeaux has the most detailed weather and vintage reports published of any region in the world, all available for free online. However, despite page upon page being written on the 2019 growing season, the vintage is not that difficult to understand. This was a hot, dry, sunny vintage that featured heavy spring rains, a hot, dry growing season, sporadic yet welcome rains in July, August, and September, and beautiful weather early in September for the Merlot harvest and similar weather in October for the Cabernet Sauvignon.

At a slightly more granular level, the season started with a dry, mild winter followed by lots of spring rains. This saturated the water table and was critical for helping the vines weather the drought and heat through the coming summer.

Flowering occurred early in June and was slightly affected by cold, rainy weather. This contributed to a small amount of coulure and uneven ripening in Merlot clusters for a handful of estates, but while a handful of châteaux commented on this phenomenon, I think this played a minor (if any) role in the final wines. A healthy fruit set resulted in average yields across the board.

Moving into the end of June, the summer turned hot and dry, and July saw temperatures peaking at over 104 degrees Fahrenheit. I was working in the Southern Rhône at this time, and I can tell you, it was hot. Nevertheless, this was pre-verasion, when heat events are less influential. For July, August, and September, rainfall was down an average of 33%.

The drought and heat resulted in tiny berries, yet small, sporadic rainstorms in July, August, and September kept the vines from shutting down and resulted in gorgeous phenolic ripeness for just about every variety out there. I have rarely tasted such silky, polished tannins in Merlot and Cabernet Sauvignon from Bordeaux.

Both August and September were hot (August slightly less so) and saw cool nighttime temperatures, which helped refresh the vines. These high daytime temperatures set the sunny style of the wines, while the cool nights contributed to the vibrant aromatics and perceived freshness in the wines. This is the paradox of 2019.

A critical rainstorm, particularly for the Cabernet Sauvignon on the Left Bank, occurred late in September, when 35 to 50 millimeters fell between the 23rd and the 26th. Most of the Merlot on the Right Bank had been harvested at this point, meaning most of the Right Bank wines were harvested before the September rains. The result is powerful, opulent wines, particularly in Pomerol, where the cooler clay soils handled the drought and heat beautifully. This is important when trying to understand the difference between the Right and Left Banks in 2019. The September rains revitalized the Cabernet Sauvignon in the Médoc and Graves region, which was largely harvested by the second week of October. While the Right Bank wines are more likely to be considered blockbusters, the Cabernet Sauvignon-dominated Médocs, as well as wines from the Graves region, show ripe yet classic Bordeaux profiles.

The Wines

The resulting wines offer everything you could want from Bordeaux: Beautiful, sunny, fruit-driven profiles that lean toward the red and blue-fruited end of the spectrum, already complex, nuanced, and vibrant aromatics, full-bodied richness, ripe tannins, and balanced profiles. In general, the wines have slightly fewer tannins than in 2018 (but I think that’s splitting hairs), pH levels are slightly down compared to 2018 as well, and alcohol levels range primarily from 13.5% to 14.5% for the Cabernet Sauvignon-based wines and 14% to 15% for Merlot-dominated wines. The perceived alcohol level (or cases where wines seem “hot”) was never a problem in any of the wines reviewed in this report. The tannin quality, as well as the purity of fruit, are the defining features of this brilliant vintage.

The Reviews

All the 2019s were reviewed via samples shipped from Bordeaux. While there can concerns with shipping unfinished wines, as barrel samples are not as stable as bottled wines, the reality is that barrel samples travel just fine. Over the past 15 years, I’ve routinely received barrel samples from France with a high degree of success, and I had no doubt that would be the case here. In addition, while critics normally taste the new Bordeaux vintage in April, where the wines have only been racked a single time, these tastings occurred in May and June, when the wines had seen an additional racking. The result is more stable wines as well as wines that are easier to judge from a barrel sample standpoint.

The wines were tasted either the day they arrived or the following day. I was also able to compare numerous barrel samples of the same wine, pulled at different times and with varying travel times, all with great success. As a whole, and as I hope the reviews show, the wines showed beautifully. In addition, it was an incredible opportunity to follow barrel samples for multiple days, do regional lineups, château comparisons, and basically spend more time with the wines than is possible while traveling in Bordeaux.

The 2019s were reviewed in two parts. First at the end of May, and then later at the end of June. This was due to a planned Central Coast trip in June, and unfortunately, I wasn’t able to receive all of the samples in time for the first report.

I have included all the reviews in this single, larger report. I was able to re-taste several wines (in some cases 3 to 4 times) after publishing Part 1 of the report, and if warranted (as was the case in a few instances), I updated those reviews.

Additional Information

Bordeaux Rising: The 2018s En Primeur

2017 Bordeaux: A Good Yet Irregular Vintage

Bordeaux 2016: Firing On All Cylinders

Let the Good Times Roll: 2015 Bordeaux from Bottle